Menu

Soups

House-made Chili, Chicken Tortilla or Wisconsin Beer Cheese

$6
Buffalo Chicken Dip

Prodigy’s Secret Blend, you won’t be disappointed, served with house chips

$10
Rock Shrimp Tempura

Prodigy brings back this Carmel favorite, Succulent Gulf Shrimp served over Frisee, tossed in an Orange Sesame Glaze

$17
Cheesesteak Eggrolls

2 Eggrolls with Prodigy’s Signature Blend, Provolone Cheese & Diced Onion, served with Chipotle Mayonnaise

$10
Sliders

3 Sliders with your choice of the: BLACKENED CHICKEN with Pepper Jack Cheese, Lettuce & Tomato or PRODIGY’S SIGNATURE BLEND topped with Gruyere, Lettuce & Tomato

$11
Thomas Edison’s Stuffed Breadsticks

Pepperoni & Mozzarella Stuffed Breadsticks served with Marinara & White Queso, Parmesan

$9
Street Tacos

3 EACH CHICKEN OR BRAISED BEEF $10 • STEAK OR SHRIMP $12
Served in Corn Tortillas, topped with Fresh Peppers, Queso Fresco, Pico de Gallo, finished with Salsa Verde

$10 - $12
Prodigy Nachos

House-made Chips, topped with Braised Beef, White Queso, Jalapenos, Pico de Gallo, Sour Cream & Guacamole

$14
12 wings

FRIED FLAVORS: Classic Buffalo, Thai Chili, Ginger Teriyaki, Sweet & Smokey BBQ
SMOKED FLAVORS: Louisiana, Sriracha, The Prodigy Smokehouse, Jamaican Jerk
ALL WINGS SERVED WITH YOUR CHOICE OF RANCH OR BLEU CHEESE

$16
18 wings

FRIED FLAVORS: Classic Buffalo, Thai Chili, Ginger Teriyaki, Sweet & Smokey BBQ
SMOKED FLAVORS: Louisiana, Sriracha, The Prodigy Smokehouse, Jamaican Jerk
ALL WINGS SERVED WITH YOUR CHOICE OF RANCH OR BLEU CHEESE

$23
24 wings

FRIED FLAVORS: Classic Buffalo, Thai Chili, Ginger Teriyaki, Sweet & Smokey BBQ
SMOKED FLAVORS: Louisiana, Sriracha, The Prodigy Smokehouse, Jamaican Jerk
ALL WINGS SERVED WITH YOUR CHOICE OF RANCH OR BLEU CHEESE

$30
Chicken Caesar Salad

Fresh greens topped with grilled chicken, croutons, parmesan, and Prodigy’s special caesar dressing

12
Berry Spring Salad

Mixed Greens, Walnuts, Mixed Berries, Apple Slices, Sun-Dried Tomatoes, tossed in Apple Vinaigrette Dressing

$12
Hot Chicken Salad

Romaine & Iceberg Lettuce, Nashville Hot Chicken, Crumbled Bleu Cheese, Dill Pickle, Celery, Carrots & our House-made Bleu Cheese Dressing

$14
7-Iron

Bigger than your normal wedge. Applewood Smoked Bacon, Crumbled Bleu Cheese, Tomato & our House-made Bleu Cheese Dressing

$9
Grilled Shrimp Salad

Artisan Greens, Shrimp, Avocado, Tomato, Cucumber & Red Onion served with House-made Spicy Dill Ranch

$13
The Innovator

Stacked Salad with Kale, Apples, Cranberries, Pecans, Grilled Chicken, tossed in our House-made Apple Vinaigrette. Can you name this innovative genius whose favorite food was Kale?

$11
The Fire and Ice

Our Signature Beef Blend Patty is coated with a Sriracha Rub and topped with Creamy Fontina Cheese

$11
The Wanna-Be GOAT

This is our Signature Blend Plain, however you get to “play GM” and select any of our ingredients to help you achieve your goals, $1 per added player

$9
Crabby Patty

This is our House-made Crab Cake Patty with Cucumber Relish & a side of Ginger Dressing

$14
The Turducken

Named affectionately for the greatest NFL broadcaster of all time, this Turkey Burger is topped with Asian Slaw, PepperJack Cheese, Avocado & Dijon Mustard served with Duck Fat Pomme Frites & garnished with our Signature Prodigy Chicken Wing

$13
Nacho Mamma

Prodigy’s Signature Blend topped with the accouterments from our Prodigy Nachos

$12
The Crasian

Prodigy’s Signature Blend topped with Peanut Butter, Bacon, Jalapenos & Smoked Gouda

$11
Sheriff

A few Greats from Tennessee. Prodigy’s Signature Blend topped with Swiss, Cheddar & Jack Daniel’s Bourbon Glaze

$11
Mozart

Prodigy’s Signature Blend topped with Bleu Cheese, Fried Onion Straws & Zesty Orange Dill Sauce. A Symphony for your taste buds.

$12
The G.O.A.T.

This Single Prodigy Signature Blended Patty topped with Special Sauce, Lettuce, Cheese, Pickle, Onion on a Sesame Seed Bun & 4 Slices of Applewood Smoked Bacon

$14
The BBQ Brisket Burger

Our Signature Wagyu Beef Blend patty is topped with Prodigy’s Slow-Roasted BBQ Brisket and Cheddar Cheese

$15
The 16th Masterpiece

Our Signature Wagyu Blend with 16 Mushrooms, Swiss, & topped with Fontina Cream Cheese

$15
The Captain

Signature Wagyu Blend topped with American Cheese, Pork Belly & Truffle Mayo

$15
The Prodigy Burger

Our Signature Wagyu Blend topped with PepperJack, Cheddar, Mushrooms, Caramelized Onion, Red & Green Peppers, & Garlic Aioli

$16
The Prodigy BBQ Brisket Sandwich

6 Ounces of our House-Smoked Beef Brisket marinated in Sweet Baby Ray’s BBQ Sauce and topped with Crispy Onion Straws

$12
The Prodigy BBQ Sandwich

Our In-House Slow-Roasted Pulled Pork basted with Sweet Baby Ray’s BBQ Sauce. Topped with Cole Slaw and Pickles.

$11
The Hoosier

An Indiana Tenderloin Breaded and topped with Dijon Mustard.

$13
Stu Unger

Grilled Chicken, PepperJack Cheese, Roasted Red Peppers, Avocado, Tortilla Strips, & Chipotle Mayo

$12
The Cheesehead

Sourdough Bread topped with Cheddar, PepperJack, Swiss, Gruyere Cheeses, Tomato, Avocado, & Applewood Smoked Bacon

$12
Farmer’s Market

Cauliflower, Rice, Black & Red Beans, Oats, Faro, Onion, Red Pepper, Basil, Tamari Sauce, topped with Sautéed Onions, Mushrooms, Provolone Cheese, served with Steamed Broccoli. Served on a Gluten-free Bun

$14
Steak and Cheese Wrap

Thinly Sliced Sirloin, House-Made Queso, Red & Green Peppers wrapped in a Jalapeno Cheddar Tortilla.

$12
Veggie Wrap

Roasted Red & Green Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms, Grilled Zucchini, Pepperjack Cheese, & Asian Slaw in a Spinach Tortilla.

$10
Buffalo Chicken Wrap

Hand-Battered Crispy Fried Chicken tossed in Buffalo Sauce topped with Bleu Cheese, Shredded Mozzarella, Lettuce, and Tomato. Served in a Jalapeno Cheddar Tortilla.

$11
Turkey Florentine Wrap

Sliced Roasted Turkey, American Cheese, Sautéed Spinach in a Spinach Tortilla. Served with a side of Fresh Fruit.

$10
The Prodigy Potato

A daily special using influence from some of our most popular burgers!

$8
Mexitato

Shredded Braised Beef, Pepperjack Cheese, Pico Di Gallo, Sour Cream, and Guacamole

$8
Veggietato

Red & Green Peppers, Mushrooms, Grilled Zucchini, Broccoli, and Swiss Cheese

$8
Chili Max Potato

Our House-Made Chili topped with Cheddar Cheese, Sour Cream, and Red Onions

$8
Winner-Winner Chicken Dinner

Lightly Breaded & Fried Nashville Hot Chicken served with Slaw & Prodigy’s Signature 3 Cheese Mac

$16
Fajitas

Served with Green & Red Peppers, Onions & our Fajita Sauce, Guacamole, Pico de Gallo, Sour Cream & Cilantro Lime Rice.

CHICKEN $14 • STEAK OR SHRIMP $16

$14 - $16
The Captain Ahab

A whale sized portion of Beer Battered Cod served with Coleslaw & Fries

$16
Kung-Pao Chicken

Marinated, Spicy Stir-fried Chicken & Broccoli, served with Cilantro Lime Rice, topped with Sesame Seeds & Green Onions

$12
Prodigy Signature 3-Cheese Mac

Shhh… it’s a secret recipe

$8
Shrimp Mac

Cavatappi Noodles, Shrimp, Signature 3 Cheese Sauce

$12
Short Rib Mac

Cavatappi Noodles, Braised Beef, Signature 3 Cheese Sauce

$10
Sriracha Mac

Cavatappi Noodles with Sriracha Seasoning and Prodigy’s 3 Cheese Sauce

$8
Side Salad with Ranch
$5
Sweet Potato Fries with a Caramel Sauce
$4
Steamed Broccoli
$4
Onion Rings
$4
Truffle Fries
$4
Fries
$3
Cole Slaw
$3
Fresh Fruit
$4
Duck Fat Pomme Frites
$5
Grilled Chicken & Broccoli
$6
Pepperoni Pizza
$6
Kids Mac & Cheese
$6
Mini Cheeseburgers (2)
$6
Grilled Cheese
$6
Chicken Tenders
$6
Lunch

Choose a half Sandwich, Slider, Soup, or Salad Combo
PICK TWO-$10 | PICK THREE-$15


½ SANDWICHES:
$10 - $15
THE CHEESEHEAD

SOURDOUGH, CHEDDAR, PEPPERJACK, SWISS, GRUYERE, TOMATO, AVOCADO, & APPLEWOOD SMOKED BACON

THE STU UNGER

GRILLED CHICKEN, PEPPERJACK, ROASTED RED PEPPERS ,AVOCADO, TORTILLA STRIPS, & CHIPOTLE MAYO

THE HOOSIER

HALF PORTION TENDERLOIN BREADED WITH DIJON MUSTARD


½ SALADS:
HOT CHICKEN SALAD

ROMAINE AND ICEBERG LETTUCE, NASHVILLE HOT CHICKEN, CRUMBLED BLEU, DILL PICKLE, CELERY, CARROTS, & HOUSEMADE BLEU CHEESE DRESSING

WEDGE SALAD

ICEBERG LETTUCE, APPLEWOOD SMOKED BACON, CRUMBLED BLEU, TOMATO, & HOUSEMADE BLEU CHEESE DRESSING

HOUSE SALAD

ROMAINE, GRAPE TOMATO, CUCUMBER, CROUTONS, & RANCH DRESSING


CUPS OF SOUP:

CHILI, WISCONSIN BEER CHEESE, CHICKEN TORTILLA, OR SOUP OF THE DAY

Brandy Alexander

Brandy – Creme de Cacao – Chocolate Ice Cream – Whipped Cream – Nutmeg

$11
Cinnamon Toast Crunch Milkshake

Vanilla Ice Cream – Rumchatta – Fireball

$11
Spiked Root Beer Float

Vanilla Ice Cream – Jägermeister – Root Beer – Whipped Cream and Cherry

$13
Pineapple Upside down Cake

Vanilla Ice Cream – Fresh Pineapple – Spiced Rum – Dark Rum – topped with fresh whipped cream and a cherry.

$11
The Dude

Marshmallow Vodka – Kahlua – Chocolate Ice Cream – Oreos – topped with whipped cream and a cherry.

$11
Girl Scout Cookie

Vanilla Ice Cream – Vodka–Godiva Chocolate Liqueur–Bailey’s– Crème de Menthe with whipped cream and a cherry

$11
Deep South

Jim Beam Bourbon – Vanilla Ice Cream – Chocolate Syrup


Non-Alcoholic Milkshakes:
$10
Chocolate Madness

Chocolate Ice Cream – Oreos – Chocolate Syrup – Whipped Cream and Cherry

$6 Regular $9 Large
Cookies and Cream

Vanilla Ice Cream – Oreos – Whipped Cream and Cherry

$6 Regular $9 Large
Creamsicle

Vanilla Ice Cream – Orange – Orange Juice – Milk – Orange Garnish

$6 Regular $9 Large
Root Beer Float

Vanilla Ice Cream – Root Beer – Whipped Cream

$8 Regular $11 Large
Milkshake

Vanilla Ice Cream –Chocolate syrup – Whipped Cream and Cherry

$5 Regular $8 Large